Impact of Environment and Social Gradient on Leptospira Infection in Urban Slums
1 Centro de Pesquisas Gonçalo Moniz, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Ministério da Saúde, Salvador, Brazil 2 Secretária Estadual de Saúde da Bahia, Salvador, Brazil 3 Escola Nacional da Saúde Pública, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Ministério da Saúde, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 4 Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil 5 Division of International Medicine and Infectious Diseases, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, New York, New York, United States of America
Leptospirosis has become an urban health problem as slum settlements have expanded worldwide. Efforts to identify interventions for urban leptospirosis have been hampered by the lack of population-based information on Leptospira transmission determinants. The aim of the study was to estimate the prevalence of Leptospira infection and identify risk factors for infection in the urban slum setting.
Methods and Findings
We performed a community-based survey of 3,171 slum residents from Salvador, Brazil. Leptospira agglutinating antibodies were measured as a marker for prior infection. Poisson regression models evaluated the association between the presence of Leptospira antibodies and environmental attributes obtained from Geographical Information System surveys and indicators of socioeconomic status and exposures for individuals. Overall prevalence of Leptospira antibodies was 15.4% (95% confidence interval [CI], 14.0–16.8). Households of subjects with Leptospira antibodies clustered in squatter areas at the bottom of valleys. The risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies was associated with household environmental factors such as residence in flood-risk regions with open sewers (prevalence ratio [PR] 1.42, 95% CI 1.14–1.75) and proximity to accumulated refuse (1.43, 1.04–1.88), sighting rats (1.32, 1.10–1.58), and the presence of chickens (1.26, 1.05–1.51). Furthermore, low income and black race (1.25, 1.03–1.50) were independent risk factors. An increase of US$1 per day in per capita household income was associated with an 11% (95% CI 5%–18%) decrease in infection risk.
Deficiencies in the sanitation infrastructure where slum inhabitants reside were found to be environmental sources of Leptospira transmission. Even after controlling for environmental factors, differences in socioeconomic status contributed to the risk of Leptospira infection, indicating that effective prevention of leptospirosis may need to address the social factors that produce unequal health outcomes among slum residents, in addition to improving sanitation.
Resumo traduzido para no português pelo Dr. Guilherme Ribeiro (Abstract translated into Portuguese by Dr. Guilherme Ribeiro).
Leptospirosis, a life-threatening zoonotic disease, has become an important urban slum health problem. Epidemics of leptospirosis now occur in cities throughout the developing world, as the growth of slum settlements has produced conditions for rat-borne transmission of this disease. In this prevalence survey of more than 3,000 residents from a favela slum community in Brazil, Geographical Information System (GIS) and modeling approaches identified specific deficiencies in the sanitation infrastructure of slum environments—open sewers, refuse, and inadequate floodwater drainage—that serve as sources for Leptospira transmission. In addition to the environmental attributes of the slum environment, low socioeconomic status was found to independently contribute to the risk of infection. These findings indicate that effective prevention of leptospirosis will need to address the social factors that produce unequal health outcomes among slum residents, in addition to improving sanitation.
Citation: Reis RB, Ribeiro GS, Felzemburgh RDM, Santana FS, Mohr S, et al. (2008) Impact of Environment and Social Gradient on Leptospira Infection in Urban Slums. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2(4): e228. doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.
Editor: Ricardo E. Gurtler, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina
Received: January 22, 2008; Accepted: March 27, 2008; Published: April 23, 2008
Copyright: © 2008 Reis et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This work was supported by the US National Institutes of Health (grants NIAID R01 AI052473, FIC D43 TW00919), Brazilian National Research Council (grants 300861/1996, 473082/2004, 420067/2005, 305723/2006, 150176/2007), and Oswaldo Cruz Foundation (grant 0250.250.102). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
* E-mail: email@example.com
# These authors contributed equally to this work.
Semantic publication details
Semantic enhancement: The semantic enhancements to the original PLoS NTD paper by Reis et al (2008) were created by David Shotton, Alistair Miles, Graham Klyne and Katie Portwin, Image Bioinformatics Research Group, Department of Zoology, University of Oxford. This enhanced version of the paper was published on 3 September 2008 at doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.x001, and revised 18 April 2009.
Explanation of semantic enhancementa: A paper describing the full range of semantic enhancement applied to the Reis et al. (2008) article has been published: Shotton et al. (2009) Adventures in semantic publishing: exemplar semantic enhancements of a research article. PLoS Computational Biology 5 (4): e1000361. http://www.ploscompbiol.org/doi/pcbi.1000361.
A description of the technical implementation of these semantic enhancements is given by Shotton and Portwin (2009) at doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.x009. A separate annotation guidelines document (Portwin and Shotton, 2009; doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.x010) describes the heuristics applied when deciding which textual terms were to be assigned to the semantic classes highlighted in the text of the enhanced version of the Reis et al. (2008) article.
A wider review of the current state and potential usefulness of semantic publication is given in a separate paper by Shotton (2009) Semantic Publishing: the coming revolution in scientific journal publishing. Learned Publishing Volume 22 (2), 85–94. http://dx.doi.org/10.1087/2009202.
Copyright: Semantic enhancements © 2008, 2009 University of Oxford. This enhanced version, as is the original paper, is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: This enhancement work was undertaken without external funding.
Competing interests: David Shotton was a judge for the Elsevier Grand Challenge, but the enhancements for this paper were made independently from that competition and preceded his access to competitors' EGC entries. The other authors of the enhancements have declared that no competing interests exist.
Acknowledgements: The authors of the enhancements thank the authors of the original paper and the editors and publisher of PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases for their support in undertaking these enhancements, and particularly thank Drs Albert Ko, Renato Barbosa Reis and Guilherme de Sousa Ribeiro for their helpful feedback on these enhancements and for making available the numerical datasets underlying Table 1, Figure 2 and Figure S2.
Correspondence: For feedback and correspondence concerning the semantic enhancements to this paper, please e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
At present, one billion of the world's population resides in slum settlements . This number is expected to double in the next 25 years . The growth of large urban populations which are marginalized from basic services has created a new set of global health challenges ,. As part of the Millennium Development Goals , a major priority has been to address the underlying poor sanitation and environmental degradation in slum communities which, in turn, are the cause of a spectrum of neglected diseases which affect these populations ,,.
Leptospirosis is a paradigm for an urban health problem that has emerged due to recent growth of slums ,. The disease, caused by the Leptospira spirochete, produces life-threatening manifestations, such as Weil's disease and severe pulmonary hemorrhage syndrome for which fatality is more than 10% and 50%, respectively –. Leptospirosis is transmitted during direct contact with animal reservoirs or water and soil contaminated with their urine ,. Changes in the urban environment due to expanding slum communities has produced conditions for rodent-borne transmission ,. Urban epidemics of leptospirosis now occur in cities throughout the developing world during seasonal heavy rainfall and flooding ,–. There is scarce data on the burden of specific diseases that affect slum populations , however leptospirosis appears to have become a major infectious disease problem in this population. In Brazil alone, more than 10,000 cases of severe leptospirosis are reported each year due to outbreaks in urban centers , whereas roughly 3,000, 8,000 and 1,500 cases are reported annually for meningococcal disease, visceral leishmaniasis and dengue hemorrhagic fever, respectively, which are other infectious diseases associated with urban poverty –. Case fatality (10%) from leptospirosis  is comparable to that observed for meningococcal disease, visceral leishmaniasis and dengue hemorrhagic fever (20%, 8% and 10%, respectively) in this setting ,,. Furthermore, leptospirosis is associated with extreme weather events, as exemplified by the El Niño-associated outbreak in Guayaquil in 1998 . Leptospirosis is therefore expected to become an increasingly important slum health problem as predicted global climate change , and growth of the world's slum population  evolves.
Urban leptospirosis is a disease of poor environments since it disproportionately affects communities that lack adequate sewage systems and refuse collection services ,,. In this setting, outbreaks are often due to transmission of a single serovar, L. interrogans serovar Copenhageni, which is associated with the Rattus norvegicus reservoir , –. Elucidation of the specific determinants of poverty which have led to the emergence of urban leptospirosis is essential in guiding community-based interventions which, to date, have been uniformly unsuccessful. Herein, we report the findings of a large seroprevalence survey performed in a Brazilian slum community (favela). Geographical Information System (GIS) methods were used to identify sources for Leptospira transmission in the slum environment. Furthermore, we evaluated whether relative differences in socioeconomic status among slum residents contributed to the risk of Leptospira infection, in addition to the attributes of the environment in which they reside.
Study site and population
The study was conducted in the Pau da Lima community (Figure 1A) which is situated in the periphery of Salvador, a city of 2,443,107 inhabitants  in Northeast Brazil. Pau da Lima is a region of hills and valleys, which was a sparsely inhabited area of Atlantic rain forest in the 1970s and subsequently transformed into a densely-populated slum settlement (Figure 1B) due to in-migration of squatters. In total, 67% of the population of Salvador and 37% of the urban population in Brazil reside in slum communities with equal or greater levels of poverty as that found in Pau da Lima ,.
Figure 1. Slum community site in the city of Salvador, Brazil.
(A) The yellow line in the aerial photograph is the boundary of the study site in the Pau da Lima community. The map in the bottom left corner shows the location of Salvador in Brazil and the study site (red) within the city. (B) Photograph of the typical environment at the community study site, which shows a valley in which households are situated and the proximity of households to open sewers and refuse. (C) Close-up view of the orthomap used to georeference households (red and black dots) and environmental attributes, such as open sewers (blue line) and refuse deposits, for the region marked as a yellow box in Panel A. The red arrow represents the direction from which the photograph in Panel B was taken.doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.g001
A study site was established which comprised of four valleys in an area of 0.46 km2 (Figure 1A). Active hospital-based surveillance found that the mean annual incidence of severe leptospirosis was 57.8 cases per 100,000 population at the study site between 1996 and 2001 (unpublished data). The study team conducted a census during visits to 3,689 households within the site in 2003 and identified 14,122 inhabitants. Households were assigned sequential numbers. A computer-based random number generator was used to select a list of 1,079 sample households from a database of all enumerated households. Eligible subjects who resided in sample households and had five or more years of age were invited to be a study participant. Subjects were enrolled into the study between April 2003 and May 2004 according to written informed consent approved by the Institutional Review Boards of the Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, Brazilian National Commission for Ethics in Research, and Weill Medical College of Cornell University.
The study team of community health workers, nurses and physicians conducted interviews during house visits and administered a standardized questionnaire to obtain information on demographic and socioeconomic indicators, employment and occupation, and exposures to sources of environmental contamination and potential reservoirs in the household and workplace. Responses reported by subjects were used to obtain information on race. The study team evaluated literacy according to the ability to read standardized sentences and interpret their meaning. Informal work was defined as work-related activities for which the subject did not have legal working documents. The head-of-household, defined as the member who earned the highest monthly income, was interviewed to determine sources and amounts of income for the household. Subjects were asked to report the highest number of rats sighted within the household property and the site of work-related activities. The study team surveyed the area within the household property to determine the presence of dogs, cats and chickens.
Geographical Information System (GIS) survey
An ArcView version 8.3 software system (Environmental Systems Research Institute) database was constructed with georeferenced aerial photographs and topographic maps provided by the Company for Urban Development of the State of Bahia (CONDER). Photographs of the study site, which had a scale of 1:2,000 and spatial resolution of 16 cm, were taken in 2002. During the census, the study team identified households within the study site and marked their positions onto hard copy 1:1,500 scale maps (Figure 1C), which were then entered into the ArcView database. A survey was conducted during the seasonal period of heavy rainfall between April and August 2003 to geocodify the location of open sewage and rainwater drainage systems. During three time points within this period, the study team mapped the sites of open accumulated refuse and measured the area of these deposits. Mean values for areas of refuse deposits were calculated and used for the analyses.
Sera were processed from blood samples collected from subjects during house visits. The microscopic agglutination test (MAT) was performed to evaluate for serologic evidence of a prior Leptospira infection . A panel of five reference strains (WHO Collaborative Laboratory for Leptospirosis, Royal Tropical Institute, Holland) and two clinical isolates  were used which included L. interrogans serovars Autumnalis, Canicola and Copenhageni, L. borgspetersenii serovar Ballum, and L. kirschneri serovar Grippotyphosa. The use of this panel had the same performance in identifying MAT-confirmed cases of leptospirosis during surveillance in Salvador , as did the WHO recommended battery of 19 reference serovars . Screening was performed with serum dilutions of 1:25, 1:50 and 1:100. When agglutination was observed at a dilution of 1:100, the sample was titrated to determine the highest titer.
Information for subjects was double entered into an EpiInfo version 3.3.2 software system (Centers for Diseases Control and Prevention) database. Chi-square and Wilcoxon rank sum tests were used to compare categorical and continuous data, respectively, for eligible subjects who were and were not enrolled in the study. A P value ≤0.05 in two-sided testing was used as the criterion for a significant difference. Preliminary analyses evaluated a range of MAT titers as criteria for prior Leptospira infection and found that the use of different cut-off values (1:25–1:100) identified similar associations with respect to the spatial distribution of seropositive subjects and risk factors for acquiring Leptospira antibodies. A titer ≥1:25 was therefore used to define the presence of Leptospira antibodies in the final analyses. The presumptive infecting serovar was defined as the serovar against which the highest agglutination titre was directed . Crude prevalence rates were reported since age and gender-adjusted values did not differ significantly from crude values. Ninety-five percent confidence intervals (CI) were adjusted for the cluster sampling of households.
Kernel density estimation analysis was performed with a range of bandwidths (10–120 meters) to evaluate smoothed spatial distributions of subjects with Leptospira antibodies and all subjects. The R version 2.4.1 statistical package (R Foundation for Statistical Computing) was used to obtain estimates which were adjusted for boundary effects. The ratio of the Kernel density estimators for subjects with Leptospira antibodies and all subjects was measured to determine the smoothed population-adjusted risk distribution. A digital terrain model of topographic data was used (ArcGIS 3D Analyst Extension software) to obtain continuous estimates of altitude for the study area. The distances, calculated in three-dimensional space, of households to nearest open drainage systems and refuse deposits were evaluated as proxies of exposure to these sources of environmental attributes. Elevation of households with respect to the lowest point in the valley in which they were situated was used as a surrogate for flood risk. Generalized additive models (GAM)  were used to evaluate the functional form of the association between continuous variables and the risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies. When indicated, continuous variables were categorized in multivariate analyses according to the x-intercept value observed in the plots of fitted smoothed values.
We used Poisson regression  to estimate the effect of demographic, socioeconomic, household and workplace-related factors on the prevalence of Leptospira antibodies. A Bayesian inference approach was used which incorporated two random effects in order to account for overdispersion and cluster sampling within households. This approach has been used to estimate parameters in complex models  and is less sensitive to sparse data . Standard non-informative prior distributions were used in models which were fitted with WinBUGS version 1.4.2 (MRC Biostatistics Unit). In multivariate analysis, all variables which had a P value below 0.10 in univariate analyses were included in the initial model. In order to address co-linearity among variables, we identified sets of covariates with the high Spearman correlation coefficients (>0.3 or <−0.3). Highly correlated variables were aggregated in a single variable when indicated, and evaluated in the model. The final model was obtained which used backward variable selection with an inclusion rule of P value <0.05.
Among 3,797 eligible residents from the slum community site, 3,171 (84%) were enrolled in the study. Study subjects had a higher proportion of females (56% of 3,171 subjects versus 37% of 626 subjects, respectively; P<0.05) and younger mean age (25.8±15.2 versus 28.1±14.6 years, respectively; P<0.05) than eligible residents who did not participate in the study. The kernel distribution of enrolled subjects according to place of residence was similar on visual inspection to that of residents who did not participate (data not shown). The majority (85%) of subjects were squatters who did not have legal title to their domiciles. Subjects belonged to mostly mixed (pardo, 66%) or black (28%) racial groups. Median household per capita income for study subjects was US$ 1.30 per day. Among the subjects, 76% had not completed elementary school education and 23% were illiterate. Among 2,077 subjects ≥18 years of age, 77% did not have formal employment and 35% engaged in informal work.
Among the 3,171 subjects, 489 had Leptospira agglutinating antibodies, as determined by the presence of MAT titer ≥1:25 (Figure 2). Highest titers were directed against L. interrogans serovar Copenhageni in 436 (89.2%) of the 489 subjects with Leptospira antibodies. For the 22 subjects (4.5%) who had highest titers against two or more serovars, agglutination reactions recognized Copenhageni as one of the serovars. Copenhageni was the predominant serovar (88–100%) recognized for the range of highest reciprocal titers (Figure 2).
Figure 2. Distribution of reciprocal microscopic agglutination test titers for 3,171 subjects from the slum community site.
Raw Data for Figure 2 (30KB XLS Spreadsheet)
Labels above the bars indicate the number of subjects (% of total), according to their highest reciprocal titer. The open bar represents seronegative subjects. Subjects with highest reciprocal titres against L. interrogans serovar Copenhageni, multiple serovars and serovars other than Copenhageni are shown as black bars, grey bars and crosshatched bars, respectively.doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.g002
The overall prevalence of Leptospira antibodies was 15.4% (95% CI 14.0–16.8). The crude prevalence among enrolled subjects was not significantly different from the prevalence (15.9%, 95% CI 14.6–17.1) which was adjusted for the age and gender distribution of eligible subjects in the study population. Prevalence was highest among adolescents and adults (16.2% and 21.2% for age groups 15–24 and >44 years, respectively). However, 8.3% (95% CI 6.2–10.5) of children 5–14 years of age had evidence for a prior exposure to Leptospira. The prevalence was higher in males than females (17.8 versus 13.6%, respectively; PR 1.32, 95% CI 1.10–1.57) (Table 1). Similar associations with age and gender were observed when MAT titers of ≥1:50 and ≥1:100 were used to define subjects with Leptospira antibodies.
Table 1. Risk factors for Leptospira antibodies among subjects at the slum community site.
Raw Data for Table 1 (82KB XLS Spreadsheet)doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.t001
Panels A and B in Figure 3 show smoothed spatial distributions of subjects with Leptospira antibodies and all subjects, respectively, according to place of residence. The population-adjusted distribution (Figure 3C) showed that risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies clustered in areas occupied by squatters at the bottom of valleys (Figure 3D). Similar spatial distributions were observed in analyses that used higher titer values to define subjects with Leptospira antibodies (Figure S1).
Figure 3. Spatial distribution of subjects with Leptospira antibodies and all enrolled subjects, according to place of residence, and environmental attributes of the community site.
Map showing overlay with leptospirosis incidence data in Salvador (data taken from ).
Panels A and B show the smoothed Kernel density distribution of subjects with Leptospira antibodies (N = 489) and all (N = 3,171) subjects, respectively, according to place of residence. The yellow-to-red gradient represents increasing density in smoothing analyses which used 40 meters as the bandwidth. Black circles show the location of subject households. Panel C shows the distribution of the population-adjusted Kernel density estimator for subjects with Leptospira antibodies which was calculated as the ratio of the estimators for subjects with Leptospira antibodies and all subjects. Panel D shows a topographic map generated by the digital terrain model. The yellow line is the level that is 20 meters above the lowest point in the four valleys within the community site. Panels E and F show the distribution of, respectively, open rainwater and sewage drainage systems and accumulated refuse according to size (m2).doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.g003
Univariate analysis found the risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies to be associated with increasing age, male gender, indicators of low socioeconomic level, occupations that entail contact with contaminated environments, informal work, time of residence in the study household, and environmental attributes and the presence of reservoirs in the households (Table 1). Significant risk associations were not found for formal employment and reported sighting of rats in the workplace environment. Open rainwater drainage structures and refuse deposits were distributed throughout the site; yet open sewers were more frequently encountered at the bottom of valleys (Figure 3). The distance of household to the nearest open sewer was a risk factor, whereas a significant association was not observed for distance to an open rainwater drainage system.
GAM analysis showed that the risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies had an inverse linear association with the distance of the subject's household to an open sewer and elevation of the household from the lowest point in the valley, a proxy for flood risk (Figure 4). Increased risk was observed among subjects who resided less than a threshold distance of 20 meters to these attributes (Figure 4B and C). The risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies had an inverse non-linear association with distance of the subject's household to an open refuse deposit (results not shown). We explored a range of dichotomization criteria and found significant risk associations when subjects resided less than 20 meters from an open refuse deposit (Table 1). This association was not influenced by the size of the refuse deposit. Subjects who reported sighting two or more rats in the household environment had increased risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies (Figure 4D). Household per capita income had an inverse linear association with the presence of Leptospira antibodies (Figure 4A). Of note, the distance of the household to an open sewer was highly correlated (Spearmen correlation coefficient = 0.71) with household elevation (Figure S2A) since open sewers drain into the bottom of valleys. An aggregate variable, distance of household located less than 20 meters from an open sewer and lowest point in a valley, was therefore used to examine the association between open sewer and flood-related exposure and infection risk (Table 1). In contrast household per capita income was not highly correlated (Spearmen correlation coefficient = 0.16) with the elevation of the household (Figure S2B).
Figure 4. Generalized additive models (GAM) of the association between the risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies and continuous variables of (A) per capita daily household income, (B) level of household in meters above the lowest point in valley, and (C) distance in meters to the nearest open sewer , and (D) reported number of rats sighted in the household environment.
The coefficient, f(infection), in the GAM model is a measure for the risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies. In Panels A, B, C and D, the x axis intercept values, where f(infection) equals zero, were US$1.70/day, 22 meters, 22 meters and 2 rats, respectively.doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.g004
Multivariate analyses found that the risk for acquiring Leptospira antibodies was associated with exposures in the household environment and not in the workplace setting (Table 1). Subjects who resided less than 20 meters from an open sewer and the lowest point in the valley had a 1.42 times (95% CI 1.14–1.75) increased risk for acquiring Leptospira antibodies than those who lived 20 meters or more from these attributes. Residence less than 20 meters from accumulated refuse was associated with a 1.43 times (95% CI 1.04–1.88) increased risk. Sighting of two or more rats and presence of chickens, a marker for rat infestation, in the household were significant reservoir-associated risk factors. After controlling for age, gender and significant environmental exposures, indicators of low socioeconomic level, household per capita income (PR 0.89 for an increase of US$1.00 per day, 95% CI 0.82–0.95) and black race (PR 1.25, 95% CI 1.03–1.50) were risk factors for acquiring Leptospira antibodies (Table 1).
Efforts to identify interventions for urban leptospirosis have been hampered by the lack of population-based information on transmission determinants. In this large community-based survey of a slum settlement in Brazil, we found that 15% of the residents had serologic evidence for a prior Leptospira infection. The prevalence rate of Leptospira antibodies in the study slum community was similar to that (12%) found in a city-wide survey performed in Salvador . Risk factors for acquiring Leptospira antibodies were associated with exposures in the household environment. Interventions therefore need to target the environmental sources of transmission - open sewers, flooding, open refuse deposits and animal reservoirs - in the places where slum inhabitants reside. After controlling for the influence of poor environment, indicators of low socioeconomic status were found to be independently associated with the risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies. This finding suggests that in slum communities with overall high levels of absolute poverty, relative differences in socioeconomic level contribute to unequal outcomes for leptospirosis.
Leptospirosis has been traditionally considered an occupational disease, since work-related activities are frequently identified as risk exposures . However slum inhabitants reside in close proximity to animal reservoirs and environmental surface waters which contain Leptospira . We previously found that Leptospira infection clusters within households in slum communities in Salvador . In this study, we found that after controlling for confounding factors, significant risk exposures were those associated with the household environment rather than workplace. As a caveat, interview-elicited responses were used to evaluate work-related exposures since GIS surveys were not performed at the sites where subjects worked. It is possible that slum residents may have had work-related risk exposures which were not detected by our survey. Nevertheless, our findings support the conclusion that the slum household is an important site for Leptospira transmission and provides the rationale for interventions that target risk exposures in this environment.
The study's findings indicate that the domestic rat was the principal reservoir for Leptospira transmission in the study community. Highest agglutination titers among 89% of the subjects were directed against L. interrogans serovar Copenhageni, the serovar associated with the R. norvegicus reservoir. Reported sighting of rats is considered to be an unreliable marker of rat infestation. However we found that the number of rats sighted by residents was correlated with their risk of acquiring Leptospira antibodies (Figure 4D), indicating that rat sightings may be a useful marker of infection risk in slum communities where inhabitants are accustomed to the presence of rats. Although dogs were not found to be a risk factor, detailed investigations of Leptospira carriage in urban reservoirs need to be performed. Of note, the presence of chickens in households was a risk factor, although they in of themselves are not reservoirs. This association may reflect a rat-related exposure not accounted for by reported sightings, since rats are attracted to chicken feed and waste. Raising chickens is a widespread practice in slum communities – 48% (519) of the 1079 study households raised chickens. Control of rodent reservoir populations may therefore need to incorporate measures that directly address this practice.
Our findings confirm hypotheses raised by previous ecologic studies ,, that infrastructure deficiencies related to open sewers, flooding and open refuse deposits are transmission sources for leptospirosis in the slum environment. Furthermore, there appears to be defined areas of risk associated with open sewers and refuse deposits, which serve as habitats and sources of food for rats. Home range radius of the domestic rat varies from 30–150 meters ,, but home range use decreases from the centre to the edge. GAM analysis demonstrated that slum residents had a positive risk for acquiring Leptospira antibodies when households were situated within 20 meters from open sewers and refuse deposits. In addition, infection risk increased as distances from an open sewer or refuse deposit decreased, suggesting that households which are situated closer to these foci have a higher degree of environmental contamination with Leptospira and inhabitants of these households are exposed to higher inoculum doses during infection. Molecular approaches to quantify Leptospira in environmental samples  will be useful in answering this question and guiding recommendations for environmental decontamination and barrier control measures which can be implemented in slum communities.
In addition, GAM analysis found that residents had positive risk for Leptospira infection when their households were situated within 20 meters from the lowest point in the valley (Figure 4B). In Salvador ,,, and other urban centers ,,,,, outbreaks of leptospirosis occur during heavy rainfall and flooding events. Slum communities are built on the poor land quality and often in areas susceptible to frequent flooding. At the study site and other slum settlements in Salvador, the water table rises up to one meter during flooding events because of inadequate rainwater drainage and blockage of drainage systems with silt and refuse. The finding that subjects had increased infection risk when their households were located within 20 meters from the lowest point in the valley suggests that this distance was a proxy for the degree of contact which residents encounter flood-related exposures in the peri-domiciliary environment.
We found that in addition to attributes of the environment where slum inhabitants reside, low per capita household income and black race, an indicator of health inequality in Brazil ,, were independent risk factors for Leptospira infection. The social gradient in health is a widespread phenomenon ,. Our findings, although not unexpected, are noteworthy since they suggest that differences in status contribute to unequal health outcomes in a slum community where the household per capita income was less than US$1 per day for 44% of the inhabitants. Although errors in the measurement of risk exposures and residual confounding factors were a possibility, the strength of the association indicates a role for social determinants in Leptospira transmission. These factors may relate to risky behaviors, such as cleaning open sewers after flooding events, or limited use of protective clothing which reduce the risk of abrasions that facilitate entry of the Leptospira spirochete . Low status and lack of access to amenities and social support are features of disadvantaged communities  which conceivably influence risk behaviors for leptospirosis. Further research is needed to evaluate the role of social factors such that effective interventions, including health education, can be implemented at the community level.
A limitation of our study was the cross-sectional design which used serologic evidence for a prior Leptospira infection as the outcome. The MAT is the standard assay used in prevalence surveys , yet there is not an established titer criterion for defining seropositive reactions. We previously found that a MAT titer of ≥1:25 was a specific marker for prior Leptospira infection among slum residents from Salvador and when applied, identified household clustering of infection risk . In this study, cutoff titers from 1:25 and above identified similar risk associations. In Salvador, leptospirosis is due to transmission of a single agent, L. interrogans serovar Copenhageni ,. Titers of 1:25, as well as higher titers, were directed against this serovar (Figure 1), indicating that this cutoff was a specific and more sensitive criteria for identifying prior infections in a region where a single serovar agent is circulating. In the study, there were more men and younger subjects among non-participating subjects than participating subjects. Crude prevalence was not different from the prevalence of Leptospira antibodies which was adjusted by the age and gender distribution of the overall study population, indicating that differences between participating and non-participating subjects may not have introduced a significant bias in the estimates. Infections may have occurred up to five years prior to the survey since agglutinating antibodies may persist for this period ,. Major interventions to improve basic sanitation were not implemented in the study community, yet the possibility that environmental exposures were modified over time can not be excluded. Migration may have affected our ability to estimate prevalence and risk associations. An on-going cohort investigation of subjects enrolled in this study found that the annual out-migration rate is approximately 12% (unpublished data). The study's findings therefore need to be confirmed in prospective studies.
We found that Leptospira transmission was due to the interaction of factors associated with climate, geography and urban poverty. Since the study was performed in a single community in Salvador, Brazil, our findings may not be generalizable to other slum settings. However, a large proportion of the world's slum population resides in tropical climates similar to that in Salvador. Moreover, similar conditions of poverty and environmental degradation encountered at the study site (Figure 1B) are found in many slum settlements. In Brazil, 37% of the urban population resides in slums with equal or greater levels of poverty as found in the study community . Our findings may therefore be relevant to other slum communities where leptospirosis is endemic and have increasing significance as global climate change , and growth of the world's slum population occur in the future ,.
The infrastructure deficiencies which were found to be transmission factors for Leptospira in this study can be readily addressed by improving sanitation in slum communities. Investment in sanitation is a cost-effective health intervention ,. In Salvador, a city-wide sanitation program (Bahia Azul) was recently shown to have a major beneficial impact for diarrheal disease . However, as frequently encountered with large-scale sanitation projects, the Bahia Azul program did not provide coverage to the study community and many of the slum settlements in the city's periphery. Equitable access to improved sanitation is therefore essential in reducing the burden of the large number of environmentally-transmitted infectious diseases, including leptospirosis, which affects slum populations. Furthermore, the finding that the social gradient within slum communities, in addition to the unhealthy environment, contributes to the risk of Leptospira infection suggests that prevention of urban leptospirosis will need to combine approaches for improving sanitation with approaches that identify and address the social determinants which produce unequal health outcomes.
Smoothed Kernel density distribution of subjects with microscopic agglutination test titres of ≥1:25 (A), ≥1:50 (B) and ≥1:100 (C), according to place of residence at the study site. The yellow-to-red gradient represents increasing density in smoothing analyses which used 40 meters as the bandwidth.
(2.61 MB TIF)
Raw Data for Figure S2 (280KB XLS Spreadsheet)
Spot plots of the relationship between elevation of household level from the lowest point in valley and distance of the household to the nearest open sewer (A) and household per capita daily income (B). Closed and open dots represent houses with at least one seropositive subject and without a seropositive subject, respectively.
(1.02 MB TIF)
We would like to thank team members from the Urban Health Council of Pau da Lima and Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, Rosan Barbosa, Reinaldo Barreto, Jorge Costa, Maria Raimunda da Cruz, Ana Carla Duarte, Leila Gouveia, Analéa Lima, Simone Nascimento, Osmar Paixão, Amaro Silva and Érika Sousa who participated in the data collection for the study. We would also like to thank the Company for Urban Development of the State of Bahia (CONDER) for providing digital maps of the study site, Elves Maciel and Alicia Chang for their assistance in designing the study; Claudio Pereira da Sá (in memorium) and Edilane Gouveia for assistance with the statistical analysis; Earl Francis Cook Jr. for critical advice during data analysis and manuscript preparation; and Lee Riley, Art Reingold and Maurício Barreto for reviewing the final manuscript. Finally, this work could not be accomplished without the joint collaborative effort of the resident associations that comprise the Urban Health Council of Pau da Lima and community leaders and residents.
Citation typing and downloadable reference list
The citations in this paper have been typed using terms from CiTO, the Citation Type Ontology, an ontology for describing the nature of reference citations in scientific research articles and other scholarly works on the Semantic Web. CiTO was created by David Shotton with assistance from Katie Portwin and Alistair Miles, and is available from http://purl.org/net/cito/, which uses content negotiation to deliver to the user an OWLDoc Web version of the ontology if accessed via a Web browser, or the OWL ontology itself if accessed from an ontology management tool such as Protégé (http://protege.stanford.edu/).
In consultation with the authors of this article, each cited reference has been assigned:
(a) One or more CiTO terms describing the relationship between this citing paper and the cited work, from the point of view of this citing paper (Relationship Object Properties in CiTO).
(b) A CiTO term describing the nature or type of the cited work (Sub-classes of Work in CiTO).
(c) A CiTO term describing the nature or type of the expression of the cited work (Sub-classes of Expression in CiTO).
(d) A CiTO term describing the nature or type of the manifestation of the cited work's expression (Sub-classes of Manifestation in CiTO) (Optional - used where useful).
(e) A CiTO term describing the peer review status of the cited work (Boolean true / false value of Object Property peerReviewed in CiTO).
The human-readable terms used here are the labels of the respective object properties and classes within CiTO, 'humanized' by the addition of spaces to make them more readable (e.g. Journal Article rather than JournalArticle).
This citation typing information is revealed in the reference list below by clicking the Turn citation typing on button below.
The complete reference list from this article, with these citation typings and with metadata recording numerical citation frequency information, is downloadable in RDF (Notation3) from doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0000228.x004, to which there is an additional link at the end of this document. The numerical citation frequency information includes both the number of in-text citations of each referenced work within this article, and the number of citations each reference has received globally, as determined from Google Scholar and the ISI Web of Knowledge on 11 March 2009.
1. (2003) The challenge of slums: Global report on human settlements 2003. London: Earthscan Publications Ltd. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Book, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 2. (2007) Slum health: Diseases of neglected populations. BMC Int Health Hum Rights 7: 2. DOI PubMed PubMedCentral (CiTO: obtains background from, shares authors with, Opinion, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 3. (2005) The 21st century health challenge of slums and cities. Lancet 365: 901–903. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, Opinion, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 4. (2000) United Nations Millennium Declaration. Link. (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 5. (2005) Focusing on improved water and sanitation for health. Lancet 365: 810–812. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, Opinion, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 6. (1999) Urban epidemic of severe leptospirosis in Brazil. Salvador Leptospirosis Study Group. Lancet 354: 820–825. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, uses data from, confirms, extends, shares authors with, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 7. (2005) Leptospirosis. Curr Opin Infect Dis 18: 376–386. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, shares authors with, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 8. (2003) Leptospirosis: A zoonotic disease of global importance. Lancet Infect Dis 3: 757–771. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 9. (2001) Leptospirosis. Clin Microbiol Rev 14: 296–326. DOI PubMed PubMedCentral (CiTO: obtains background from, uses method in, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 10. (2006) Determining risk for severe leptospirosis by molecular analysis of environmental surface waters for pathogenic Leptospira. PLoS Med 3: e308. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, confirms, extends, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 11. (2000) Socio-environmental determinants of the leptospirosis outbreak of 1996 in western Rio de Janeiro: A geographical approach. Int J Environ Health Res 10: 301–313. DOI PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, confirms, extends, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 12. (1979) Leptospirosis in the city of Salvador, Bahia, Brazil: A case-control seroepidemiologic study. Int J Zoonoses 6: 85–96. PubMed (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 13. (2002) Leptospirosis in children in Mumbai slums. Indian J Pediatr 69: 855–858. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 14. (2005) Leptospirosis during dengue outbreak, Bangladesh. Emerg Infect Dis 11: 766–769. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 15. (2003) Human leptospirosis: A twenty-nine-year serological study in Sao Paulo, Brazil. Rev Inst Med Trop Sao Paulo 45: 245–248. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 16. (2002) Population-based case-control investigation of risk factors for leptospirosis during an urban epidemic. Am J Trop Med Hyg 66: 605–610. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, uses data from, shares authors with, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 17. (2004) [Spatial distribution of leptospirosis in the city of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 1996–1999]. Cad Saude Publica 20: 1721–1729. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 18. (2000) The relationship between rainfall and human leptospirosis in Florianopolis, Brazil, 1991–1996. Braz J Infect Dis 4: 131–134. [No Link Found] (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 19. (2007) [Leptospirosis case notification records, Brazil]. [No Link Found] (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Print Document, not peer reviewed) 20. (2008) [Dengue epidemiological report, January–December 2007]. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 21. (2007) [Confirmed cases of meningococcal disease, Brazil, major regions and federal units, 1990–2006]. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 22. (2007) [visceral leishmaniasis case notification records, Brazil]. [No Link Found] (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Print Document, not peer reviewed) 23. (2007) [Meningococcal disease deaths, Brazil, major regions and federal units, 1990–2006]. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 24. (2007) [visceral leishmaniasis case fatality rate, Brazil, major regions and federal units, 2000–2006]. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 25. (1998) El fenómeno El Niño en Ecuador.; Organización Panamericana de la Salud, editor. El Niño, 1997–1998. Washington, D.C.: Organización Panamericana de la Salud. pp. 175–230. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 26. (1999) Climate and health. Science 285: 347–348. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 27. (2005) Impact of regional climate change on human health. Nature 438: 310–317. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 28. (2001) Identification of new repetitive element in Leptospira interrogans serovar copenhageni and its application to PCR-based differentiation of Leptospira serogroups. J Clin Microbiol 39: 191–195. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, uses data from, shares authors with, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 29. (2000) A clonal subpopulation of Leptospira interrogans sensu stricto is the major cause of leptospirosis outbreaks in Brazil. J Clin Microbiol 38: 450–452. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 30. (2006) Molecular characterization of Leptospira sp. strains isolated from human subjects in Sao Paulo, Brazil using a polymerase chain reaction-based assay: A public health tool. Mem Inst Oswaldo Cruz 101: 373–378. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 31. (2002) Censo demográfico 2000 - resultados do universo. Rio de Janeiro: Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 32. (2005) Mapamento da pobreza em áreas urbanas do estado da Bahia. CD-ROM 2005. [No Link Found] (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Digital Media Object, not peer reviewed) 33. (2003) Slums of the world: The face of urban poverty in the new millennium? Nairobi: UN-HABITAT. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Report, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 34. (2003) Human leptospirosis: Guidance for diagnosis, surveillance and control. Malta: World Health Organization. Link (CiTO: uses method in, Reference Work, Report Document, Online Document, not peer reviewed) 35. (1999) Dichotomization of continuous measurements using generalized additive modelling–application in predicting intrapartum caesarean delivery. Stat Med 18: 1101–1110. DOI (CiTO: uses method in, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 36. (2003) Alternatives for logistic regression in cross-sectional studies: An empirical comparison of models that directly estimate the prevalence ratio. BMC Med Res Methodol 3: 21. DOI (CiTO: uses method in, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 37. (2006) Bayesian statistics in medicine: A 25 year review. Stat Med 25: 3589–3631. DOI (CiTO: uses method in, obtains support from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 38. (2000) Problems due to small samples and sparse data in conditional logistic regression analysis. Am J Epidemiol 151: 531–539. Link (CiTO: uses method in, obtains support from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 39. (2007) Factors associated with Leptospira sp infection in a large urban center in Northeastern Brazil. Rev Soc Bras Med Trop 40: 499–504. DOI (CiTO: confirms, shares authors with, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 40. (2008) Household transmission of Leptospira infection in urban slum communities. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 2: e154. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, confirms, shares authors with, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 41. (1982) Norway rat and allies. In: Chapman JA, Feldhamer GA, editors. Wild mammals of North America. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 1077–1088. Link (CiTO: uses data from, Reference Work, Book, not peer reviewed) 42. (1991) Walker's mammals of the world. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press. Link (CiTO: uses data from, Reference Work, Book, not peer reviewed) 43. (2001) Ethnicity and infant health in Southern Brazil. A birth cohort study. Int J Epidemiol 30: 1001–1008. DOI (CiTO: uses data from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 44. (2004) The concept and measurement of race and their relationship to public health: A review focused on Brazil and the United States. Cad Saude Publica 20: 660–678. DOI (CiTO: uses data from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 45. (2001) Inequalities in health. N Engl J Med 345: 134–136. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Editorial, JournalItem, not peer reviewed) 46. (2005) Social determinants of health inequalities. Lancet 365: 1099–1104. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 47. (2002) Leptospirosis: Skin wounds and control strategies, Thailand, 1999. Emerg Infect Dis 8: 1455–1459. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 48. (2001) Persistence of anti-leptospiral IgM, IgG and agglutinating antibodies in patients presenting with acute febrile illness in Barbados 1979–1989. Eur J Epidemiol 17: 601–608. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 49. (1991) Serological follow-up of patients involved in a localized outbreak of leptospirosis. J Clin Microbiol 29: 805–809. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 50. (2007) Global cost-benefit analysis of water supply and sanitation interventions. J Water Health 5: 481–502. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Review, Journal Article, peer reviewed) 51. (2006) Intervention cost-effectiveness: Overview of general messages. In: Jamison DT, Breman JG, Measham AR, Alleyne G, Claeson M et al., editors. Disease control priorities in developing countries. New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 35–86. Link (CiTO: obtains background from, Review, Book Chapter, not peer reviewed) 52. (2007) Effect of city-wide sanitation programme on reduction in rate of childhood diarrhoea in northeast Brazil: Assessment by two cohort studies. Lancet 370: 1622–1628. DOI (CiTO: obtains background from, Research Paper, Journal Article, peer reviewed)